Danny, Jamie, Erin – Which Reagan Sibling Do You Want in Your Family Most?

For over a decade, “Blue Bloods” has invited us into the lives of the Reagan family, a dynasty of New York City law enforcement. While Frank Reagan holds the top spot as Commissioner and the patriarch, his children—Danny, Jamie, and Erin—each bring a distinct personality and approach to justice that makes them incredibly compelling. If you were lucky enough to be adopted into the Reagan clan, which sibling would you want by your side through thick and thin?

“If You Were a Reagan, Would You Be Danny, Jamie, or Erin?”

Let’s break down the unique qualities of these three formidable Reagans:

Danny Reagan: The Fiery, Intuitive Detective

Danny Reagan is the oldest of the siblings and a seasoned NYPD detective. He’s known for his hot temper, his willingness to bend the rules (or at least push them to their limit) to get the job done, and his incredibly direct, no-nonsense approach to crime. He’s often driven by raw emotion, especially when victims are involved, which can lead to explosive confrontations but also to passionate, relentless pursuit of justice.

  • Why you’d want him: If you value unwavering loyalty, someone who will fight tooth and nail for you, and a detective who trusts his gut and gets results, Danny’s your guy. He’ll always have your back, no matter the cost.

Jamie Reagan: The Calm, Principled Officer

Jamie Reagan is the youngest and, arguably, the most by-the-book of the siblings. A Harvard Law graduate who chose the beat over the courtroom, Jamie is calm, thoughtful, and deeply principled. He’s a stickler for fairness and due process, often acting as the moral compass of the family when it comes to police work. He’s passionate about protecting the vulnerable and ensuring justice is served by the rules.

  • Why you’d want him: If you appreciate a steady hand, a thoughtful perspective, and someone who always strives to do things the right way, Jamie is your ideal family member. He brings quiet strength and unwavering integrity.

Erin Reagan: The Sharp, Resilient Prosecutor

Erin Reagan is the only daughter and an Assistant District Attorney. She’s incredibly intelligent, fiercely independent, and principled in her own right, often grappling with the ethical dilemmas that arise when the law meets reality. She’s tough in the courtroom, but also deeply empathetic to victims, showcasing a strong sense of justice that sometimes clashes with her father’s or brothers’ police perspectives.

  • Why you’d want her: If you need sharp legal advice, a keen mind to help navigate complex situations, and a strong, independent woman who isn’t afraid to stand her ground, Erin is the perfect addition to your family. She’ll argue her case with brilliance and passion.

“Three Personalities – Three Choices – Who Do You Belong With in the Blue Bloods Family?”

So, which Reagan sibling resonates most with you? Would you thrive in Danny’s intense world, appreciate Jamie’s calm guidance, or find common ground with Erin’s sharp intellect? Perhaps you see a bit of yourself in all three.

Related articles

Dante Falconeri embraces Lulu and reveals “positive news”—but could it be concealing a more profound family sorrow? Who will face the ultimate consequences?

Dante Falconeri Hugs Lulu and Shares “Good News”—But is It Masking a Deeper Family Tragedy? Who Will Pay the Ultimate Price? In the world of daytime dramas,…

Blue Bloods’ Worldwide Streaming Boom Proves Fans Are Eager for Donnie Wahlberg’s Spinoff

Blue Bloods fans are proving that the recently concluded series is still capable of dominating the streaming charts. After its recent cancellation, a new spinoff starring Donnie…

Boston Blue Casting Revealed: Meet the Stars Behind the Blue Bloods Spinoff

CBS has officially greenlit the Blue Bloods spinoff Boston Blue, set to premiere October 17, 2025. The series follows Donnie Wahlberg’s Detective Danny Reagan as he leaves the streets of…

Donnie Wahlberg Breaks Silence on CBS Programming Shifts—and the Possibility of a Blue Bloods Spinoff

Blue Bloods’ cancellation was a real bummer, and it was something that no one in the cast wanted to happen. However, the Reagan family’s story gets to…

‘Blue Bloods’ Beloved Cast Member Shares Excitement About Joining a New Crime Series

Beloved ‘Blue Bloods’ Star Talks Returning to TV For New Crime Drama (Exclusive) originally appeared on Parade. Amy Carlson appeared in seven seasons of Blue Bloods as…

‘Boston Blue’: Which ‘Blue Bloods’ Character Do You Most Want to See in a Cameo?

CBS is airing starting up Blue Bloods reruns starting Friday, August 15, with the Season 4 finale at 10/9c. The reruns will return two weeks later on Friday, August 29,…